Can he relate to the way I practice Judaism?
Does he have a good bedside manner?
Will he treat me like a mentsch?
Will he view my baby as I do? Or is my baby "just another feather in the cap?"
Does he have patience?
Does he give me the time of day when I have questions related to the bris that need to be discussed?
Is he an excellent practitioner?
Will the cosmetic results be to my liking?
Do his standards of hygiene and sterility match my sensibilities?
Does he pay attention to detail?
Does he explain things clearly?
Is the baby ever in danger?
What is his track record as far as emergencies and post-op situations?
Does he check the baby after the bris?
Is he in contact to see how the baby is doing a few days along the healing process?
Is he familiar with all aspects of Jewish law related to the bris?
Is he familiar with the customs of different Jewish traditions - European, Middle Eastern, North African, etc?
Is he flexible in terms of some of the customs, as they relate to my family situation?
What is his method of circumcision?
Does he use a clamp or the "Jewish shield" to isolate the foreskin?
How does he do metzitzah?
Good luck with your baby! I hope all goes well and your experience is a positively memorable one!